More on iTunes and Modern Times

Posted on Sunday 3 September 2006

Cory Doctorow wrote to say: 

Kim, it appears that the four tracks you couldn’t burn were video- files that probably couldn’t be burned to a redbook CD, though the UI is still inexcusably confusing.

But there’s still something rotten in Denmark.

If you go to buy the plastic CD at Amazon, here is the track list you see.  Check it out.  There are two disks - an Audio CD (Disc 1) and a DVD (Disc 2):

Track Listings

Disc: 1

  1. Thunder On The Mountain  
  2. Spirit On The Water  
  3. Rollin’ and Tumblin’  
  4. When The Deal Goes Down  
  5. Someday Baby  
  6. Workingman’s Blues #2  
  7. Beyond The Horizon  
  8. Nettie Moore  
  9. The Levee’s Gonna Break  
  10. Ain’t Talkin’  
  11. Blood In My Eyes 
  12. Love Sick  
  13. Things Have Changed  
  14. Cold Irons Bound 

Dsc: 2 

  1. Cold Irons Bound (Unreleased live version from Masked & Anonymous) 
  2. Blood In My Eyes 
  3. Things Have Changed 
  4. Love Sick (From The Grammy Awards) 

In other words, Amazon says the audio CD includes the audio tracks corresponding to the videos you get on the second disk.  Isn’t that what you would expect?

The virtual product doesn’t let you do the same thing.  Who cares if it’s not DRM on the audio - but instead, DRM on the video?  I’m unable to strip the audio off the video to burn it to a CD.

I think iTunes (or is it Sony?) should have structured their download the way they did with the molecular set - giving you all the audio tracks, and letting you copy them to a CD.

As Cory says, the iTunes user interface is - in this one case - incredibly confusing.  But in truth, even if iTunes fixed it, I wouldn’t be happy with the Dylan album experience.  When I download an album I want the equivalent of the molecular product - with all of its 14 tracks, or whatever it’s supposed to have.

Meanwhile, Alex J wrote to me from England.

Alex apparently doesn’t think that videos have an audio track, or that I should expect to be able to put the soundtrack on an audio CD the way Sony did in the brick and mortar world (the miracles of modern science!).  He writes:

mmmm.. I don’t see any DRM problems at all. I don’t see any errors on the part of iTunes anywhere. I don’t see …. well, shall I tell you what I DO see?

I see a loud mouthed idiot getting hysterical over the fact that he (she?) is trying to burn 4 bonus video - VIDEO - tracks to an audio CD and is being told by iTunes that it can’t be done.

Funny that.

Now, stop frothing at the mouth, go and burn tracks 1 through 10 (ie. the audio tracks, you know, the music?), and r-e-l-a-x. Oh, and don’t forget to put up a retraction of your silly rant :-)

I guess “frothing” is not inaccurate, though hauling out the word “bonus” to legitimize the iTunization of the last four songs is a bit much - as is the implication that they don’t contain “music”. 

Getting down to brass tacks, the trouble is that Blood In My Eyes and Things Have Changed are pretty decent songs (you know, those audio things), and I don’t want them caged up inside the proprietary iTunes environment.  


22 Comments for 'More on iTunes and Modern Times'

  1.  
    September 3, 2006 | 9:15 am
     

    FYI, Modern Times is definitely only a 10 track album. The other four ‘tracks’ are merely bonus material provided on a completely separate disc with the physical version of the album. They are in no way part of the studio recordings - in fact, Blood in My Eyes is from the album ‘World Gone Wrong’, Things Have Changed is from the film ‘Wonder Boys’, and the other two tracks are non-studio versions of songs from ‘Time Out of Mind.’

    When I put the Modern Times CD in my player I only see those 10 tracks, ending with Ain’t Talkin’.

    So while it sucks that you can’t burn the video files as audio, you’re not missing out on any of Modern Times by burning just the 10 audio-only files.

    As such, it seems that the answer is “bad iTunes UI” - Apple’s site seems to have presented the ‘album’ as a 14 track collection of songs. For once I don’t think Sony (and certainly not Dylan) is to blame.

    EDIT: on further reading it seems the problem must surely be that Amazon is inaccurately representing the CD as a 14-track album.

    &nbsp

  2.  
    September 3, 2006 | 9:23 am
     

    Wow. Are you saying you bought the two-disc set and the playlist taken from the Amazon page above is wrong? I’m confused-er and confused-er.

  3.  
    September 3, 2006 | 10:07 am
     

    [...] Now it appears Amazon&nbsphad it wrong&nbspall along.&nbsp Apparently&nbspDisc&nbsp1 of the molecular version is missing the songs in the four&nbspvideos as well. [...]

  4.  
    September 3, 2006 | 2:52 pm
     

    [...] I got this information from Amazon and I suspect Cory did the same.&nbsp But I haven’t actually seen the molecular product, which is confusing because there are two versions as well, so&nbspmaybe the same problem of unrippable music exists there.&nbsp It doesn’t change much, despite what deadlocked says.&nbsp The iTunes experience is lauded for its consistency and fairness, and for the ease with which iTunes customers can convert their purchased songs into MP3s. But this is a dramatic failure of the consistency, clarity and ease of iTunes. [...]

  5.  
    September 4, 2006 | 7:48 pm
     

    [...] Ben Laurie&nbspthinks I was&nbspdamning&nbspdigital rights technology when I complained about not being being able to burn some of&nbspthe Modern Times songs I had paid for and downloaded. He writes: Kim’s got all steamed up over iTunes’ DRM. [...]

  6.  
    September 12, 2006 | 11:38 pm
     

    [...] Visit original post by Kim Cameron [...]

  7.  
    November 20, 2007 | 10:38 pm
     

    juegos instantaneos paginas web

    Amenudo jugar portales web download juego ruleta gratis

  8.  
    November 20, 2007 | 10:51 pm
     

    juego paginas internet

    Tan lejos geld gewinne juego dados

  9.  
    November 20, 2007 | 10:53 pm
     

    pai gow poker portal

    Tomorow jugar gratis linea pai gow poker portal

  10.  
    November 20, 2007 | 10:54 pm
     

    juego pagina jugar paginas web jugar pagina web

    Demême spiele bank poker run

  11.  
    November 20, 2007 | 11:21 pm
     

    poker pagina web

    Cuatro casino portales promociones casino portal web

  12.  
    November 20, 2007 | 11:48 pm
     

    poker portal

    Wennsie pai gow poker portal poker portal

  13.  
    November 20, 2007 | 11:52 pm
     

    circus circus casino resort

    En einicio juegos instantaneos paginas web jugar portales web

  14.  
    November 20, 2007 | 11:52 pm
     

    multiplayer poker

    Mucho casino portales play free casino slots

  15.  
    November 21, 2007 | 1:32 am
     

    ruleta portales

    Cuando ruleta portales download juego ruleta gratis

  16.  
    November 21, 2007 | 1:34 am
     

    juegos azar portal internet

    HeuteAbend online game gambling casino poker paginas internet

  17.  
    November 21, 2007 | 1:37 am
     

    juegos apuestas jugar apostar paginas internet

    ZudiesemPunkt pai gow poker portal top online kasinos

  18.  
    November 21, 2007 | 1:57 am
     

    jugar video poker online

    Mit ganar dinero linea sicheres spielen

  19.  
    November 21, 2007 | 2:08 am
     

    kostenloses kasino

    The virtual casino cartas linea

  20.  
    November 21, 2007 | 3:18 am
     

    multiplayer poker

    Por ejemplo poker pagina web slot machines online spielen

  21.  
    November 21, 2007 | 3:20 am
     

    pai gow poker internet

    En juego casino portales best casino gamble internet online

  22.  
    November 21, 2007 | 4:03 am
     

    kostenloses spiel

    Coger internet spielbank vegas black jack

Leave a comment